Child Sex Trafficking in Our Fair City? Say It Ain't So

Disturbing trends among teenagers reflect a growing national problem.

You might have seen that disturbing film from the mid-'80s called Blue Velvet, in which a young man discovers a sinister underworld lying just beneath his idyllic suburban home town. It came to mind recently when I went to a luncheon held in honor of Sharmin Bock, prosecuting attorney for Alameda County and candidate for San Francisco District Attorney.

As she discussed the need for greater collaboration between local cities and towns, Sharmin shared one unsettling story after the next, detailing how criminals prey on our young by coercing, forcing and trafficking them into sex slavery. Yeah, I know, not exactly something you want to hear about when you are eating cobb salad and drinking a cooling glass of ice tea. But there it is.

Sharmin told us of one Volvo-driving mother in a well-to-do town in Contra Costa County who dropped her two 13-year-old daughters off at the mall one afternoon. She didn’t see them again for weeks. They had met a seemingly nice young man who invited them over to his house to meet his friends. The girls were held hostage and repeatedly sold as sex slaves until the FBI were able to rescue them. This isn’t Thailand, people, or a made-for-TV movie; this is here.

UNICEF’s website states that as many as 1.2 million children worldwide are trafficked every year for cheap labor or sexual exploitation. According to Shared Hope International and confirmed by the U.S. Congress, more than 100,000 American children are exploited in domestic sex trafficking. The average entry age: 12-14 years old.

, founder of Fremont-based California Against Sex Slavery, explains, “Gangs are moving beyond drugs to the more lucrative sex trafficking. You can sell a person over and over again, but you can only sell a drug once.”

Sharmin says, “Human trafficking is not a Third World or international phenomenon—it is a well-documented domestic problem occurring in our own backyard.”

Oakland and Sacramento are considered national hotbeds for sex slavery. Sadly, San Mateo County is not far behind. According to Sharmin, traffickers keep their victims enslaved at the hotels that ring the San Francisco airport to service businessmen and other travelers. 

But surely, this couldn’t happen here in Our Fair City?

I reached out to Liz Schoeben, founder and executive director of Counseling and Support Services for Youth. Her organization joins with elementary, middle, and high schools up and down the Peninsula to help troubled youth. In fact, this fall they will work at six of our elementary schools here in Palo Alto.

When we spoke, Liz assured me she had not heard of any cases of the nature Sharmin had shared. And then she hesitated. “Well, there is a new, deeply disturbing trend we are seeing in the high schools. Upperclasswomen, typically seniors, are luring freshman girls to parties and pimping them out to the senior and junior boys.” 


“Oh yes, senior girls getting paid by senior boys for sex with the younger girls,” Liz clarified. “We have seen incidences of this in a number of high schools in our area.”

Beyond all of the unsettling moral issues, I wonder if those upperclasswomen realize they can be prosecuted as child sex traffickers? The laws have finally caught up with the reality of this kind of torture. State law AB 22, passed in 2005, established human trafficking as a federal crime, but the sentencing is weak. Sharmin says there is more to do.

She and others, such as Daphne Phong, are working to toughen the trafficking laws in our state.  They are lobbying to establish an initiative on the November ballot that will lengthen jail time from the maximum of eight years to life in prison, force convicted child sex traffickers to register as sex offenders, provide services for victims, and require mandatory training for law enforcement. You can learn more on their website.

I asked Liz what parents and the community could do? She said, “The best way to protect our children is to stay connected, to be in their life and to know what is going on.”  

So, I put down my laptop and went on a walk with my daughter. Just like in the movie, the yellow sun was shining, the blue and black birds were singing, and I knew there was so much more than meets the eye in our idyllic suburban town.

Lisen Stromberg September 06, 2011 at 03:48 AM
Chris, Thanks for reading. Sharmin was not intending to scare us. Her intent was to explain the importance of collaboration across law enforcement agencies in connected communities. Sadly, theses stories did make headlines. I just chose to ignore them as they were too disturbing to focus on. Lisen
Amy Zucker Morgenstern September 06, 2011 at 11:14 PM
It would be unrealistic to imagine that sex trafficking was happening in Sunnyvale, Berkeley, and San Mateo (where there have been recent prosecutions) but not in Palo Alto. Furthermore, sex trafficking is only part of the international crime that is human trafficking, a.k.a. modern slavery (the 3rd largest such criminal enterprise, after the drug and illegal-arms trades). Restaurant, agricultural and domestic workers in our midst may well be slaves unable to speak up. I recommend the organizations Free the Slaves and Not For Sale Campaign if you want to learn more and take action. I'm glad law enforcement and the judicial system are becoming more aware of this phenomenon that affects upwards of 27 million people. Rev. Amy Zucker Morgenstern http://www.uucpa.org/sermons_11/sermon110814.html
dan September 08, 2011 at 11:29 AM
Chris you're a blind and misinformed. Do the research, all over the US and the world, and yes including your community children are being sold for sex. You need a headline to prove it; just open your eyes and do the research.
dan September 08, 2011 at 11:57 AM
Chris, Go to SAGE, GEMS, MISSSEY, CALIFORNIA AGAINST SLAVERY and other organizations outside of the political arena and you will be shocked what you will learn. Men like you who refuse to see that buying children for sex is a real problem in your own backyard are part of the problem. Take a walk in Sacramento, Oakland, Pittsburg, Vallejo, Concord, Antioch, San Francisco, Richmond and in cities all over to see what is happening in front of your very eyes every day. These children some as young as 12 are also on-line being sold by pimps. My Red book, my space, face book; Every method of recruiting is used in order to get these children... And once they get caught up in the life, the blind-eye allows for the madness to continue... Until your loved one becomes a victim you will never understand. Make the leap and begin your own research. Until then you too are part of the continued victimization of our children, I say this because of your initial obvious ignorant response.
Liz June 16, 2013 at 11:34 PM
Thank you for sharing your knowledge. Have you looked into Exodus Road?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »