Toxic Hazards in Palo Alto Can no Longer Fester

Palo Alto isn't considered a place with toxic hazards, but a dangerous legacy in fact remains, and the City needs to do something about it.


Palo Alto normally is not considered at risk from toxic materials, but there are areas of contaminated groundwater and soil due to operations in the Stanford Research Park, plus spills of toxic materials in the Research Park from CPI occurred near homes. The most serious groundwater and soil contamination is by the HP Superfund sites at 1501and 640 Page Mill Rd. 

Contamination from the 1501 site is local and remains on site. Contamination from 640 Page Mill and a Varian site at 601 California Ave. extends across El Camino into the California-Olive-Emerson (COE) area.  It is being cleaned up but the pump-and-treat system seems to have reduced aquifer contamination about as low as pumping can accomplish. Addressing problems from toxics in the plating facility at CPI  also is a serious issue.

The solvent of most concern is trichloroethene (TCE), a known carcinogen likely to cause Parkinson’s disease, liver and kidney damage. Recently it was identified as causing birth defects after exposures at levels as low as 2.1 micrograms/cubic meter. 

TCE has been known to be toxic for over 100 years as a drinking water contaminant. Toxicity from breathing TCE vapors which entered occupied buildings from contaminated soil and groundwater was recognized as a serious problem in 1998.

Breathing TCE is worse than drinking contaminated water because it’s more easily absorbed into the body through the lungs. Vapor intrusion at levels above 3 micrograms/cubic meter in commercial buildings or 0.5 micrograms/cubic meter in residential buildings puts occupants at risk of serious health problems such as cancer. 

Vapor levels beneath a building’s foundation can be more than 100 times greater than levels in nearby soil, as the foundation can trap vapors allowing them to concentrate. Vapor barriers, sub-slab ventilation and regular indoor air monitoring have become standard practice to prevent vapor intrusion of harmful levels of TCE into occupied buildings. 

Unfortunately the Regional Water Quality Control Board (Water Board) which has oversight of our COE area doesn’t require vapor barriers and sub-slab ventilation under new construction, putting future occupants of those sites at unnecessary risk.

CPI which took over an old Varian building operates plating facilities that have had three spills and releases of toxic chemicals near Barron Park residences since 2006. Until last month the quantities of nitric acid and potassium cyanide were far above allowed limits under State regulations.

CPI claimed they needed thesequantities to operate effectively.  Now they say they can operate fine with smaller quantities under the maximum allowed by the State. Neighbors want the plating area moved at least 300 feet from residential properties, but CPI says they can’t do that and remain competitive. 

Of course there are other plating facilities within 20 miles of CPI that could do the work, but CPI ignores that. An alternative is to require plating operations to be removed after a 14 year amortization period, but that will continue to expose residents and people at Barron Park School to any future toxic spills. These hazards must be addressed and resolved now, not in 2026.

Wynn Grcich April 26, 2012 at 03:19 PM
When Bert was mayor, he gave a group a Parkinson's award. They claimed they did not know what caused Parkinson’s. Moss claims this chemical causes it. So does toxic metals in our water. I gave the Palo Alto council the Blaylock Wellness Report, by Dr. Russell Blaylock."Is your drinking water fit to drink?" Sept. 2004. Parkinson was caused by copper leaking from the drinking water pipes. The corrosive chemical additives Chloramine and Fluorosilicic acid cause the pipes in our house to corrode. Palo Alto takes their incinerated sewage sludge to Kettleman City at $800,000 a year. Now the council wants an anaerobic digester to mulch their copper laden sludge with tree trimmings and use this toxic brew for landscape. It will end up in underground aquifers too. The former environmentalist mayor, thought this would be a good idea to use a toxic sludge for landscaping. I bragged to others city councils, that Palo Alto takes their sewage sludge to a toxic waste dump.They should do the same, instead of selling it for fertilizer for our crops. 59 tons of phosphate fertilizer waste added to our drinking water, to prevent cavities. Dr. Howard Pollick, head of SF dental school, calls this toxic waste medicine to prevent cavities. He can’t even write a prescription for it, because it isn’t medicine. Close Kettleman City waste dump, since there is so many uses for toxic waste.People don’t mind drinking cancer causing water, because of our city council’s decisions? Wynn Grcich


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something